This guy at ExtremeTech put into words what I’ve been feeling about Games for Windows. It’s an excellent look at why Games for Windows needs to change drastically for it to be a success.
Some key points:
* Live on the PC only runs while you’re actually playing a Live-enabled game.
* The GFW – Live user-interface was designed for a controller.
* Microsoft charges for features that PC gamers have had for free for ages.
* The only publisher to support GFW – Live is Microsoft.
* No 3rd party developers are supporting it
* Epic has said why they aren’t supporting Live on the PC with Unreal Tournament 3, and what Microsoft needs to do to fix it.
* People don’t want to pay more to get less.
* Just when the Xbox 360 owners get all hyped up about the vastly superior Halo 3, the Vista users get a port of a 2.5-year-old game they should have had access to simultaneously with Xbox owners back in 2004.
* Geometry Wars is $5 on the Xbox 360, but the Vista version somehow costs $7.95.
* Two of their whopping four GFW – Live games this year are ports of old Xbox 1 games.
* They are publishing exactly zero triple-A Windows exclusives this year.
* Don’t take your premier PC developers like Ensemble Studios and have them make real-time strategy games (best suited for the PC) and task them with making an RTS exclusive to the Xbox 360 like Halo Wars.
* The Games for Windows branding and certification program is a good idea.
I will be very surprised if the current version of Games for Windows – Live is a success. I expect it to fail unless a major overhaul takes place. I polled over 800 people and almost half of them don’t want to pay for a Gold membership. They don’t want to pay for a service that has less features than they currently have.
I think all the game developers realize this. They see developing for GFW as a risky venture. Microsoft needs to make GFW an outstanding platform before other developers will jump on board. Game developers are showing more support for Xfire than they are GFW – Live.
Still, PC gaming is fun. We’ll still have our old options like Xfire for us. However, we WILL be blocked from certain features in-game if we don’t have the right subscription. That’s discouraging.
currently playing: Catan, HALO 3 beta, Guitar Hero II
anticipating: Shadowrun, HALO 2 (PC), HALO 3, Quake Wars (in that order)
rest in peace: GoW, CoD3

